Is this a fair trade??

I give:


B. Colon (LAA-SP)


B. Bonds (SF-OF)





I get:


J. Isringhausen (STL-RP)


B. McCann (ATL-C)


C. Crawford (TB-OF)

Is this a fair trade??
If i were you, i would definitely pull the trade.





Colon: hasnt pitched much, and when he has, he has struggled. All the time he has spent on the DL really impacts his value.





Bonds: overhyped.





Isringhausen: decent closer, not the best as he will blow a save here and there, but plays for the cards. Tons of opportunites there.





McCann and Crawford: both very good players for their position. Crawford's main attraction is his steals though, not much for power.
Reply:I don't think so. But thats cuz its in your favor. Do you need a closer? Crawford just had a 5 hit, 5 run, 4SB night so I would do it in a second.
Reply:make the trade quick!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply:its all one sided closers are very high value in fantasy baseball isringhausen was going for a guy like abreu or beltran in one of my leagues brian mccann is very good that dude on sportsstream keeps ravin about him and how good hes goin to be carl crawford 50 stolen bags for sure and a 290 hitter the guy will not accept this trade barry bonds is like 40 and is only gonna get 20 homers be cause of the giants having alot of depth in thier outfield and bartolo was injured earlier this year and isnt pitchin very well he and dontrelle willis both won 20 games LAST YEAR and are pitchin terrible this year look at stats not names
Reply:yes
Reply:Anything that gets Bonds off your roster is a good trade.
Reply:take it before the other guy comes to his senses!!!!
Reply:Try to get a different C than McCann. I think hes hurt.
Reply:isn't that basically colon and a random, day to day, spot duty guy like bonds for 3 solid players?





is this really a question. look at bond's numbers. they're horrible.
Reply:i'd do it.
Reply:take the trade
Reply:Yes. You are getting the best deal. Colon is injured and doesn't seem to have his good stuff. If he comes back he won't be good til VERY late in the season. Bonds isn't gonna get you good points because he is focused too much on the record. Isringhausen is gonna get A LOT of saves. McCann is a great hitting catcher and Crawford is a base stealing machine. You have to do this trade.
Reply:If i were you i would do it.....although both of you are giving up struggling players. Crawford's hanging around a 250 batting average.....Igrihausen has blown alot of saves..but McCann is hitting 340 this year. Also, yur getting rid of alot of dead weight because Colon is hurt and Bonds doesnt play alot.
Reply:If you have not done this yet I'd be very disappointed.


Bonds does not play regularly enough to warrant a slot on your daily roster. McCann may be a good second catcher for you and great trade bait when a catcher gets injured. I love having Crawford on my team.
Reply:not sure it's fair, but it's definitely a good deal for you.





Colon is hurt and isn't doing well anyway this year.


Bonds isn't going to put up big numbers for anything except walks.





Isringausen will rack up saves since the Cardinals will win lots of games.


McCann is currently hurt but is a decent catcher.


Crawford will put up great steal numbers.





So it doesn't seem to be a fair trade, but it definitely favors you.

floral