Which catcher should I pick up?

I Have: Michael Barrett





Pick Up's:


Johnny Estrada


(Mil - C) Col FA 271 298 80/277 31 8 34 0 .289


Javy López


(Col - C) NA @Mil FA 310 1179 -/- - - - - -


Mike Napoli


(LAA - C) DL Tex FA 761 595 43/177 35 8 29 4 .243


John Buck


(KC - C) @Cle FA 780 590 47/192 28 15 29 0 .245


Miguel Olivo


(Fla - C) Was FA 801 709 73/292 24 7 36 2 .250


Guillermo Rodríguez


(SF - C) LAD FA 824 1182 3/17 2 0 4 0 .176


Kurt Suzuki


(Oak - C) @Min FA 825 1183 7/23 5 2 4 0 .304


Wil Nieves


(NYY - C) @TB FA 827 1083 6/50 2 0 4 0 .120


Shawn Riggans


(TB - C) DL NYY FA 839 1132 1/10 1 0 2 0 .100


Pete LaForest


(SD - C) NA @Ari FA 840 1091 5/16 2 0 1 0 .313


Jamie Burke


(Sea - C) Det FA 848 1177 21/60 10 0 6 0 .350


Kelly Stinnett


(StL - C) NA @Phi FA 849 1144 8/44 3 1 4 0 .182


Alberto Castillo


(Bal - C) NA CWS FA 852 1046 5/31 5 1 3 0 .161


Alvin Colina


(Col - C) NA @Mil FA 857 1157 -/- - - - - -

Which catcher should I pick up?
I would pick estrada my second pick would be buck those are the only two worth dropping barrett for.
Reply:Definetely Johnny Estrada. He's the only one from the bunch who can give you a good average while hitting some homeruns and getting some RBI's.
Reply:Johnny Estrada, because of that powerful Brewers offense that will protect him and get on base for him to get RBIs and RUNS and has good power numbers for a C.
Reply:I would just keep Barret
Reply:Definitely Estrada. He will produce all around decent numbers in 4 of the 5 categories, unlike Buck who only hits HR's.